联邦最高法院接受纽约州枪支协会诉纽约市案

doublepar

开始了 ......

https://www.thetruthaboutguns.co ... -assn-v-city-of-ny/

早就有文章分析过这个案子的重要性，它不光涉及到宪法二修里“bear”的问题，还涉及到如何判断法律法规是否符合宪法二修的检验标准问题。

winterwang

大法官们这是学了孙子兵法？空城计？以退为进？

sig2013

doublepar 发表于 2020-4-28 17:16
这周五大法官开例行碰头会，现在在高院跟前的所有十个 2A 案件都列上议案了，而且排名很靠前(不知道这排 ...

uper

doublepar 发表于 2020-4-28 20:16
这周五大法官开例行碰头会，现在在高院跟前的所有十个 2A 案件都列上议案了，而且排名很靠前(不知道这排 ...

doublepar

uper 发表于 2020-4-28 16:30
求解释

这周五大法官开例行碰头会，现在在高院跟前的所有十个 2A 案件都列上议案了，而且排名很靠前(不知道这排名是否有意义)。

uper

doublepar 发表于 2020-4-28 16:41
Conference of May 1, 2020 in the United States Supreme Court

I count Culp, Pena, Mance, Worman, Gou ...

求解释

doublepar

Conference of May 1, 2020 in the United States Supreme Court

I count Culp, Pena, Mance, Worman, Gould, Ciolek, Rogers, Malpasso, Wilson and Cheeseman among the top ones. Someone is really pissed.

geforcemx

uper 发表于 2020-4-27 15:01
The Chief Justice Ducks on Gun Rights
The Court majority cowers to Senate Democratic threats

uper

doublepar 发表于 2020-4-27 11:11
Guess it has to wait. But the Court indeed vacated and remanded the lower court judgement.

Cautiou ...

The Chief Justice Ducks on Gun Rights
The Court majority cowers to Senate Democratic threats

https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-chief-justice-ducks-on-gun-rights-11588026396?mod=hp_opin_pos_1

doublepar

uper 发表于 2020-4-27 08:00
Supreme Court Sidesteps Decision on New York City Gun Regulations
https://www.wsj.com/articles/supre ...

Guess it has to wait. But the Court indeed vacated and remanded the lower court judgement.

Cautiously optimistic to see many GVR orders on cases currently sitting in front of the Court.

uper

Supreme Court Sidesteps Decision on New York City Gun Regulations
https://www.wsj.com/articles/supreme-court-sidesteps-decision-on-new-york-city-gun-regulations-11587998220?tesla=y&mod=article_inline

supergirl

不知道什么时候出结果

TofuSan

可能这个moot了也有好处，不至于在大选之前消耗保守派过多的政治能量。

z_g_yang

82页，太长了， 看到有一句JUSTICE ALITO: So then why is this  case moot? Because they didn't get all that  they wanted. They wanted a declaration that the  old law was unconstitutional, period.

aerostar

doublepar 发表于 2019-12-7 19:05
庭辩录音

庭辩记录

听了，感觉Moot还是两可的。控方的底气听上去不是很足，辩方倒是有些信心满满的样子。

uper

doublepar 发表于 2019-12-7 22:05
庭辩录音

庭辩记录

大律师给总结下吧

doublepar

庭辩录音

庭辩记录

doublepar

sbnfsj 发表于 2019-12-2 17:43
关键要看Chief Justice Roberts在mootness这个问题上的取态了

其实在今年一月份 grant certiorari 之前，按高院的惯例，大法官们会关门秘密投一次票，所以结果早就已经定了。庭辩只是作秀、走过场而已。高院大法官和助手们这么聪明的人，读读案卷就能判案，哪还会被庭辩这几句话打动而改主意。

sbnfsj

doublepar 发表于 2019-12-2 18:49
今天一个钟头庭辩时间，三刻钟在辩论 mootness，然后媒体就嗨了。实际情况是，merit 根本就没有太多争议，m ...

关键要看Chief Justice Roberts在mootness这个问题上的取态了

doublepar

今天一个钟头庭辩时间，三刻钟在辩论 mootness，然后媒体就嗨了。实际情况是，merit 根本就没有太多争议，mootness 是被告纽约市一方最后一道防线，过了这一关，被告就是一败涂地。