Clearwater, FL - Standing on your ground, or ?

doublepar

"Drejka is a legal concealed weapons permit holder and will not be charged because of Florida's Stand Your Ground law, according to the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office.
The store owner tells ABC Action News that Drejka has a history of assaulting people in the very parking lot the shooting took place. A man who frequents the store told ABC Action News he had a run-in with the man who opened fire just one month ago. Rich Kelly says the man picked a fight with him over a parking spot, using racial slurs, and even threatening to kill him. Now, a month later, a similar case, ending with a father killed in front of his 5-year-old son."

开枪的这位不咋样啊。

doublepar

单从监控录像来看，我个人认为不是个非常 clean cut 的自卫案例。对方虽然把他推在地上，但没有进一步的威胁，也没有武器。

doublepar

https://www.tampabay.com/news/pu ... ing-space_170174041

"Drejka could not be reached for comment Friday. But (Sherrif) Gualtieri said Drejka told deputies that he was he was in fear of being attacked again. He owned the gun legally and had a concealed carry permit."

当事人至少知道事后怎么说话 ......

doublepar

独孤求准 发表于 2018-7-23 10:32
这人好管闲事而已。一般人看到非法停残趴的，不会像他一样上去吵。至于用什么"racial slurs"，这不能just ...

法律、道德、情感、常识不能混在一起。
佛州的 Stand Your Ground 法比较特殊，检方有举证责任证明开枪者不是自卫，不然连 Stand Your Ground hearing 都过不去，所以他基本不会被起诉。但我不认为他的行为很明智，违反了 de-escalate/escape/avoid 的基本原则。

doublepar

Attorney: Shooter's pause could leave door open for charges

律师的意思是他打得还不够快 ...... 拔枪出来等了一两秒，就有可能是在考虑是否开枪，一有时间考虑，开枪就可能不是必要的，自卫的理由就可能说不过去。检方可以说他不是真正地害怕生命受到威胁，不符合自卫开枪的条件。
这个案子可能会很经典，拭目以待。

doublepar

独孤求准 发表于 2018-7-24 13:23
Drejka 总可以说被重重的摔一跤后，他当时已经disoriented了，隔1-2秒是当时最快的反应速度了。不能要求 ...

你很会说话啊。
不过，检察官可以说，一两秒之后，imminent threat 不存在了。

doublepar

oneMore 发表于 2018-8-13 11:42
又是一个自找麻烦的案例。有监控视频，这要比Zimmerman的案子更难脱身。大家伙引以为鉴了。 ...

Zimmerman 的案例其实是一清二楚的自卫，自卫大拿 Massad Ayoob 有很详细的分析。
Zimmerman 被控完全是出于政治原因，而且他的辩护律师根本没有引用 Stand Your Ground 法律。